Skip to main content
VOICES FROM THE GLOBAL SOUTH ON FOOD, CLIMATE AND CULTURE
POWERED BY OVER 100 CONTRIBUTING WRITERS

Sunder Lal Hora hill-stream fishes study tied fish form to fast water

Sunder Lal Hora hill-stream fishes research showed how fast Indian streams shaped fish that grip rock. In 1940 he turned to dams and migratory fish.

By
R Sukumar
November 16, 2026
3 min read

By Ritambhara

The Sunder Lal Hora hill-stream fishes research, published in 1930 in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, traced how fishes of fast Indian streams evolved organs to grip rock. In 1940 Hora, an ichthyologist at the Zoological Survey of India, wrote in Current Science about the problems dams create for migratory river fishes.

Hora was born in 1896 at Hafizabad in Punjab, now in Pakistan, and studied at Government College, Lahore. He joined the Zoological Survey of India in 1919 and led it from May 1947 until his death in Calcutta in December 1955.

Fishes shaped by fast water

Torrential streams are mountain streams in which water runs fast over boulders and gravel. The Sunder Lal Hora hill-stream fishes monograph, “Ecology, bionomics and evolution of the torrential fauna, with special reference to the organs of attachment”, runs to 112 pages. Its abstract states his view that evolution is the adaptation of organisms to their environment. Hora argued that gradations in the environment shape an animal’s characters over time. He tested the idea on the animals of torrential streams.

What later research confirmed and corrected

A 2018 study in Microscopy and Microanalysis examined four species of Garra, a carp genus with an adhesive disc under the head, from the Basistha River in Assam. Hussain and Bordoloi found taste buds and dense horny projections, called unculi, on the lips and discs. They concluded that these organs together let the fish cling to rocks in torrential streams.

Hora also cited hill-stream fishes for his Satpura hypothesis of 1949. It proposed that species from the eastern Himalaya and Malaya reached the Western Ghats through the Satpura hills of central India. In a 2003 Current Science review, K Praveen Karanth wrote that taxonomic revision had made the hypothesis untenable for these fishes. He called their similarity “yet another case of convergence”, meaning unrelated species evolved similar features in similar streams.

Dams across the path of migrating fish

Migratory fishes move between sea, estuary and upstream river reaches to breed. This series has already covered P C Mahalanobis and his flood statistics for the rivers of Bengal and Orissa. The hilsa, a shad that swims up the Ganga from the Bay of Bengal, is the best-known example in eastern India, and Bangladesh protects it with a seasonal fishing ban.

The Farakka Barrage on the Ganga, built in the 1970s, stopped hilsa runs upstream to Prayagraj, then Allahabad, according to India Water Portal (2019) and the Press Trust of India (2021). The Inland Waterways Authority of India later built a new navigation lock at Farakka, costing about Rs 361 crore, designed to ease hilsa passage (Press Trust of India, 2021).

The Living Planet Index for Migratory Freshwater Fishes, a 2024 report by WWF, the Zoological Society of London and partners, found an average 81% decline in monitored populations between 1970 and 2020. The report attributes half of the threats to habitat loss and degradation, including river fragmentation by dams.

Hora’s work treats the speed of a river, its barriers and its fish as one system. A dam or weir should be judged by whether fish can still hold their place in the current and reach their spawning grounds.

THE FOURTH PLATE IS PUBLISHED BY GLOBAL SOUTH MEDIA PVT LTD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, KERALA, INDIA